Skip to content
OpenTrain AIFor AI Companies

Researcher Tools

Human Feedback and Eval Paper Explorer

A focused feed for RLHF, preference data, rater protocols, agent evaluation, and LLM-as-judge research. Every paper includes structured metadata for quick triage.

Total papers: 88 Search mode: keyword Ranking: eval-signal prioritized Shortlist (0) RSS

Featured Papers

Popular high-signal papers with direct links to full protocol pages.

Start Here By Objective

Pick your immediate research objective and jump directly to high-signal pages, not generic search.

Scale Your Evaluation Team

Need human evaluators for your benchmark or preference study? OpenTrain sources pre-vetted domain experts into your annotation pipeline.

A Proposed Rubric for Evaluating Expressed Clinical Reasoning in Large Language Model Responses

Zhangshu Joshua Jiang, Zina Ibrahim, James T. Teo · Sep 29, 2026

Citations: 0

Match reason: Keyword overlap 3/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: high protocol signal.

Score: 100% High protocol signal Freshness: Hot Status: Ready
Rubric Rating Automatic Metrics Medicine
  • Rubrics support the structured evaluation of language models.
  • We propose a rubric for assessing expressed clinical reasoning in model responses, drawing on three bodies of work: medical education assessment frameworks (ART, SCT, Key Feature Problems and OSCE); clinical LLM benchmarks (MedR-Bench,…
Open paper
Citations: 0

Match reason: Keyword overlap 3/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: high protocol signal.

Score: 100% High protocol signal Freshness: Hot Status: Ready
Rubric Rating Simulation Env General
  • We introduce UserProxyBench, an evaluation layer over the tau-bench family, and the User Fidelity Score (UFS), which measures adherence to the benchmark's private user instructions using task-grounded rubric criteria scored independently of…
  • Holding the agent fixed at GPT-5.5 and varying only the user proxy across 375 enterprise tasks changes mean task reward by 15.2 points, while 24.4% of successful episodes contain a user-specification violation.
Open paper
OmniVCBench: Benchmarking Evidence-Grounded Multimodal Reasoning Towards AI Virtual Cells

Manyu Li, Xunkai Li, Yongfu Xiong, Yi Liu, Rong-Hua Li, Guoren Wang · Sep 29, 2026

Citations: 0

Match reason: Keyword overlap 3/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: high protocol signal.

Score: 100% High protocol signal Freshness: Hot Status: Ready
Rubric Rating Llm As JudgeAutomatic Metrics Coding
  • We introduce OmniVCBench, a figure-centric, source-traceable benchmark for the interpretation component of an AIVC.
  • Within the evaluated heterogeneous model pool, MCQ accuracy correlates positively with AIVC-Judge scores, providing a complementary view of performance alongside open-response evaluation.
Open paper
ScienceArena: Benchmarking LLMs on Latest Scientific Olympiad Competitions

Guangxiang Zhao, Qilong Shi, Xusen Xiao, Wenpu Liu, Yaoming Li, Linfeng Hao · Aug 31, 2026

Citations: 0

Match reason: Keyword overlap 3/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: high protocol signal.

Score: 93% High protocol signal Freshness: Warm Status: Ready
Rubric Rating Llm As Judge Long Horizon General
  • Benchmark saturation and data contamination increasingly obscure genuine scientific reasoning in frontier LLMs.
  • We introduce ScienceArena, an olympiad-style benchmark from thirteen public science competitions in physics, chemistry, and biology, including IPhO and IChO 2025--2026, IBO 2023, USAPhO 2026, and USNCO 2025.
Open paper
Citations: 0

Match reason: Keyword overlap 3/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: high protocol signal.

Score: 93% High protocol signal Freshness: Warm Status: Ready
Rubric Rating Llm As Judge Multi Agent General
  • Multi-Agent Debate (MAD) has been widely adopted to improve LLM-based evaluation by prompting multiple agents to negotiate and reach a consensus.
  • However, for subjective rubric-based scoring, inter-agent agreement does not guarantee alignment with human judgments.
Open paper
ExecRubrics: Executable Tool-Augmented Rubrics for Verifiable and Efficient Long-Form Evaluation

Kaustubh D. Dhole, Charles L. A. Clarke, Eugene Y. Agichtein · Aug 23, 2026

Citations: 0

Match reason: Keyword overlap 3/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: high protocol signal.

Score: 93% High protocol signal Freshness: Warm Status: Ready
Pairwise PreferenceRubric Rating Automatic Metrics General
  • On three long-form response benchmarks -- HealthBench, HelpSteer, and ArgQuality -- we show that ExecRubrics can recover substantial preference signal without an LLM judge at evaluation time.
  • We show that incorporating external logic and resources from text processing libraries such as NLTK and spaCy can further improve preference accuracy.
Open paper
ZenGen: Social Mind for LLMs

ZenGen Team, Ao Xiang, Bi Jingping, Chen Jiahui, Chen Lehan, Chen Yilin · Jul 26, 2026

Citations: 0

Match reason: Keyword overlap 3/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: high protocol signal.

Score: 93% High protocol signal Freshness: Warm Status: Ready
Rubric Rating Automatic Metrics Medicine
  • For measurement, we introduce SoMBench, a psychology-grounded benchmark spanning 3 primary dimensions, 17 secondary dimensions, and 71 task paradigms.
  • Evaluation of 20 representative LLMs reveals substantial headroom: the best model achieves only 72.08% overall accuracy, and none of the 17 secondary dimensions reaches the 90% near-ceiling band.
Open paper
Can LLM-as-a-Judge Reliably Verify Rubrics in Agentic Scenarios?

Yangda Peng, Yunjia Qi, Hao Peng, Haotian Xia, Guanzhong He, Xintong Shi · Jun 29, 2026

Citations: 0

Match reason: Keyword overlap 3/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: high protocol signal.

Score: 93% High protocol signal Freshness: Warm Status: Ready
Rubric Rating Llm As JudgeAutomatic Metrics Coding
  • Rubric-based scoring has become a widely used paradigm in model evaluation, typically with LLM-as-a-Judge (LaaJ) for rubric scoring.
  • We introduce RuVerBench, the first benchmark for assessing LaaJ reliability in rubric verification for agentic scenarios.
Open paper
Evaluating and Benchmarking the System One Model Jev

Tobias Deußer, Lorenz Sparrenberg, Rafet Sifa · Sep 29, 2026

Citations: 0

Match reason: Keyword overlap 2/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: high protocol signal.

Score: 85% High protocol signal Freshness: Hot Status: Ready
Rubric Rating Automatic Metrics LawCoding
  • We evaluate Jev (jev-1.13.0) zero-shot on 37 datasets spanning classification, routing, natural language inference, reading comprehension, commonsense reasoning, moderation, legal clause analysis and rubric scoring, with one frozen template…
Open paper
Unfolding Scientific Papers into Multi-Turn Generation Trajectories for Continued Pre-Training

Qiankai Xu, Qiguang Chen, Zixin Su, Wenhao Huang, Yue Gao, Jiaheng Liu · Aug 26, 2026

Citations: 0

Match reason: Keyword overlap 3/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: moderate protocol signal.

Score: 88% Moderate protocol signal Freshness: Warm Status: Ready
Rubric Rating Long Horizon General
  • The same reverse construction extends to instruction data and evaluation.
  • Anchoring tasks in held-out papers yields PAW-Bench, an academic-writing benchmark whose tasks carry their own rubrics and checklists.
Open paper
SkillCoach: Self-Evolving Rubrics for Evaluating and Enhancing Agentic Skill-Use

Jiayin Zhu, Kelong Mao, Yudong Guo, Dengbo He, Sulong Xu, Simiu Gu · Jul 2, 2026

Citations: 0

Match reason: Keyword overlap 3/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: moderate protocol signal.

Score: 88% Moderate protocol signal Freshness: Warm Status: Ready
Rubric Rating Automatic Metrics General
  • We introduce SkillCoach, a self-evolving rubric framework for evaluating and enhancing agentic skill-use.
  • Experiments show that evolved rubrics substantially improve evaluation quality, expose failures hidden by final accuracy, and provide stronger supervision signals than outcome-only filtering for enhancing agentic skill-use.
Open paper
SEFORA: Student Essays with Feedback Corpus and LLM Feedback Evaluation Framework

Shayan Peyghambari Oskoui, Norah Almousa, Zhaoyi Joey Hou, Carolina Gustafson, Gayle Rogers, Raquel Coelho · Jun 30, 2026

Citations: 0

Match reason: Keyword overlap 3/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: moderate protocol signal.

Score: 88% Moderate protocol signal Freshness: Warm Status: Ready
Rubric RatingCritique Edit Automatic Metrics General
  • UniMatch is a reference-based evaluation framework for open-ended generation: it segments feedback into feedback units, scores their semantic correspondence under instructor-derived criteria, and aligns them via optimal matching to yield…
Open paper

Match reason: Keyword overlap 3/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: moderate protocol signal.

Score: 88% Moderate protocol signal Freshness: Warm Status: Ready
Rubric Rating Automatic Metrics Medicine
  • We evaluate the exact deployed configuration with a layered methodology -- retriever, generator under oracle context, end-to-end, and latency -- scored by LLM judges validated against physician rubrics.
  • The evaluation relocates the hard problem.
Open paper

Match reason: Keyword overlap 2/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: high protocol signal.

Score: 78% High protocol signal Freshness: Warm Status: Ready
Rubric Rating Automatic Metrics Medicine
  • Medical question-answering benchmarks rarely cover the maternal, neonatal, child, and reproductive-health questions a nurse-midwife asks, and, to our knowledge, no public chunk-level relevance benchmark exists for maternal-health guideline…
  • We release two benchmarks that fill these gaps.
Open paper
GRPO for Financial Advice Generation: Outperforming Commercial LLMs under CATE Evaluation

Ofir Ben Shoham, Shrutendra Harsola, Vignesh Subrahmaniam, Shravan Mohan, Yakov Gazman, Oded Vainas · Aug 12, 2026

Citations: 0

Match reason: Keyword overlap 3/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: moderate protocol signal.

Score: 83% Moderate protocol signal Freshness: Warm Status: Ready
Rubric Rating Llm As Judge General
  • Our reward is an LLM-as-a-judge rubric that scores each recommendation across multiple binary dimensions of advice quality, augmented with a safety gate for harm prevention.
  • Since LLM-based evaluation alone cannot confirm whether improvements reflect genuine business value rather than adaptation to the judge, we complement it with a judge-independent audit based on a standard doubly-robust Conditional Average…
Open paper
From Personas to Plot: Character-Grounded Multi-Agent Story Generation for Long-Form Narratives

Aayush Aluru, Chloe Ho, Muhammad Hammouri, Kerry Luo, Myra Malik, Ryan Lagasse · Jul 1, 2026

Citations: 0

Match reason: Keyword overlap 3/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: moderate protocol signal.

Score: 83% Moderate protocol signal Freshness: Warm Status: Ready
Pairwise PreferenceRubric Rating Multi Agent General
  • MAGNET, a multi-agent goal-driven narrative engine for storytelling, generates stories with persona-grounded character agents that propose actions based on a shared world state and evolving story goals, while ATLAS is a graph-based pipeline…
  • At 100 pages, MAGNET reduced annotations and hallucinations by 41 and 50%, respectively, compared to the single model baseline and by 34 and 45%, respectively, compared to IBSEN, with pairwise rubric evaluation showing similar results.
Open paper
Automated grading of Linux/bash examinations using large language models: a four-level cognitive taxonomy approach

Manuel Alonso-Carracedo, Ruben Fernandez-Boullon, Pedro Celard, Francisco J. Rodriguez-Martinez, Lorena Otero-Cerdeira · Jul 2, 2026

Citations: 0

Match reason: Keyword overlap 2/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: moderate protocol signal.

Score: 73% Moderate protocol signal Freshness: Warm Status: Ready
Rubric Rating Automatic Metrics General
  • Gemini~3.0 Pro with rubric-guided prompting achieved the highest human-AI agreement (ICC(3,1) = 0.888, MAE = 0.10, Bland-Altman bias = -0.014).
  • These results show that question complexity is a reliable predictor of the difficulty LLMs face in grading accurately, and they establish a principled, taxonomy-based framework for determining which questions are suitable for AI-assisted…
Open paper
Citations: 0

Match reason: Keyword overlap 3/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: sparse protocol signal.

Score: 78% Sparse protocol signal Freshness: Warm Status: Fallback
Pairwise PreferenceRubric Rating General
  • In this survey, we introduce a Bayesian framework that defines constitutions as prior distributions P(R) over evaluation criteria and rubrics as conditional instantiations R_x \sim P(R|x).
  • Under this unified view, we present a taxonomy of rubric-guided RL along the prior-posterior axis, covering constitutional AI, instance-specific rubrics, process-level supervision, self-evolving rubrics, and their agentic and multimodal…
Open paper

Match reason: Keyword overlap 3/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: sparse protocol signal.

Score: 78% Sparse protocol signal Freshness: Warm Status: Fallback
Rubric Rating General
  • Agricultural applications, however, are domain-specific, region-dependent, time-sensitive, and safety-critical.
  • Without data governance, expert evaluation, and evidence constraints, an agricultural assistant mayproduce unreliable advice on crop diseases, pesticide use, fertilization, or policy interpretation.To avoid presenting unverified simulated…
Open paper
Rubric Dropout: A Simple Way to Mitigate Reward Hacking in Rubric-as-Reward RL

Minglai Yang, Xinyu Guo, Utkarsh Tyagi, Mian Zhang, Razvan Dumitru, Sunjie Hou · Aug 12, 2026

Citations: 0

Match reason: Keyword overlap 2/3 across title and protocol fields. Eval-signal density: moderate protocol signal.

Score: 68% Moderate protocol signal Freshness: Warm Status: Fallback
Rubric Rating Medicine
  • Reinforcement learning against rubrics, lists of criteria graded by an LLM judge, has become a standard way to post-train language models on tasks with no deterministic answer.
  • Comparing no dropout against dropout at 30% and 50% on both benchmark pairs, dropout raises the OOD gold score at every matched checkpoint (+1 to +2 points on HealthBench-Hard, +6 to +7 points on ResearchQA), lowers the two hacking measures…
Open paper