Skip to content
OpenTrain AIFor AI Companies

HFEPX · Eval paper review

Can Programs Replace LLM Judges? Executable Program Judges for Scalable and Efficient Relevance Labeling

Eugene Agichtein, Charles L. A. Clarke, Kaustubh Dhole, William Stern

Published

Nov 18, 2026

Citations

0

Trust level

Low

Usefulness score

2/100 (Low)

Extraction confidence

40% (Low)

Derived from extracted protocol signals and abstract evidence.

Rater population

Not reported

Signals refreshed

Nov 18, 2026

Should you rely on this paper?

This paper is adjacent to HFEPX scope and is best used for background context, not as a primary protocol reference.

Use this as background context only. Do not make protocol decisions from this page alone.

Best use

Background context only

Use if you need

A secondary eval reference to pair with stronger protocol papers.

What to verify

Read the full paper before copying any benchmark, metric, or protocol choices.

Main weakness

This paper looks adjacent to evaluation work, but not like a strong protocol reference.

Human feedback signal
Not explicit
Not explicit in abstract metadata
Evaluation signal
Detected
Eval setup described
Usefulness for eval research
2/100
Adjacent candidate

Treat as adjacent context, not a core eval-method reference.

Abstract

Large language model (LLM) judges have become a common way to create large-scale relevance judgments for retrieval evaluation. However, each judgment requires a potentially expensive call to a frontier model, and the judgments are hard to interpret and may not be reproducible. In this paper, we ask whether an LLM can write a readable program for each topic that replaces its per-document judgments. To address these issues, we propose ExecJudges, a method for generating fast, inspectable and scalable judges for automatic relevance labeling. Specifically, ExecJudges uses a frontier LLM to turn assessment guidelines into executable programs, which rely only on lexical matching, standard NLP libraries like parsers, and pool statistics. An ExecJudges-L variant also uses examples of human labels if available. We evaluate ExecJudges on seven TREC collections by comparing the produced labels with trained NIST assessors, frontier LLM judges, and recently proposed per-topic classifiers. Our results show that ExecJudges agrees with NIST assessors at the level of the Claude Sonnet 5.5 LLM judges on TREC DL 2019-2021. With a small number of human labels per topic, the ExecJudges-L variant agrees with NIST more than per-topic classifiers with the same labels on all seven collections, and either exceeds the agreement of LLM judges provided the same labels or is within about 0.05 of it in Krippendorff's alpha. The labels rank the official TREC DL runs with Kendall's tau of 0.87 to 0.94, and writing the programs incurs a one-time cost of $0.17 to $0.49 per topic, with no additional costs for grading. Our results suggest that ExecJudges offers a reproducible, inspectable, efficient and cost-effective alternative to LLM judges for labeling deep result pools for system evaluation or ranking improvements.

What we could verify

These are the protocol signals we could actually recover from the available paper metadata. Use them to decide whether this paper is worth deeper reading.

Human Feedback Types

missing

None explicit

No explicit feedback protocol extracted.

"Large language model (LLM) judges have become a common way to create large-scale relevance judgments for retrieval evaluation."

Evaluation Modes

partial

Llm As Judge

Includes extracted eval setup.

"Large language model (LLM) judges have become a common way to create large-scale relevance judgments for retrieval evaluation."

Quality Controls

partial

Inter Annotator Agreement Reported

Calibration/adjudication style controls detected.

"Large language model (LLM) judges have become a common way to create large-scale relevance judgments for retrieval evaluation."

Benchmarks / Datasets

missing

Not extracted

No benchmark anchors detected.

"Large language model (LLM) judges have become a common way to create large-scale relevance judgments for retrieval evaluation."

Reported Metrics

missing

Not extracted

No metric anchors detected.

"Large language model (LLM) judges have become a common way to create large-scale relevance judgments for retrieval evaluation."

Benchmarks and datasets

No benchmark or dataset names were extracted from the available abstract.

Reported metrics

No metric terms were extracted from the available abstract.

Human feedback details
Uses human feedback
No
Feedback types
None
Rater population
Not reported
Expertise required
General
Evaluation details
Evaluation modes
Llm As Judge
Agentic eval
None
Quality controls
Inter Annotator Agreement Reported
Evidence quality
Low
Use this page as
Background context only

Research brief

Metadata summary

Large language model (LLM) judges have become a common way to create large-scale relevance judgments for retrieval evaluation.

Based on abstract + metadata only. Check the source paper before making high-confidence protocol decisions.

Key takeaways

  • Large language model (LLM) judges have become a common way to create large-scale relevance judgments for retrieval evaluation.
  • However, each judgment requires a potentially expensive call to a frontier model, and the judgments are hard to interpret and may not be reproducible.
  • In this paper, we ask whether an LLM can write a readable program for each topic that replaces its per-document judgments.

Researcher actions

  • Compare this paper against nearby papers in the same arXiv category before using it for protocol decisions.
  • Check the full text for explicit evaluation design choices (raters, protocol, and metrics).
  • Use related-paper links to find stronger protocol-specific references.

Caveats

  • Generated from abstract + metadata only; no PDF parsing.
  • Signals below are heuristic and may miss details reported outside the abstract.

Contribution summary

  • Large language model (LLM) judges have become a common way to create large-scale relevance judgments for retrieval evaluation.
  • However, each judgment requires a potentially expensive call to a frontier model, and the judgments are hard to interpret and may not be reproducible.

Why it matters for eval

  • To address these issues, we propose ExecJudges, a method for generating fast, inspectable and scalable judges for automatic relevance labeling.

Researcher checklist

  • Human feedback protocol is explicit

    No explicit human feedback protocol detected.

  • Evaluation mode is explicit

    Detected: Llm As Judge

  • Quality control reporting appears

    Detected: Inter Annotator Agreement Reported

  • Benchmark or dataset anchors are present

    No benchmark/dataset anchor extracted from abstract.

  • Metric reporting is present

    No metric terms extracted.