Quantitative Analysis of Automatic Image Cropping Algorithms: A Dataset and Comparative Study

Q: What is the best open-source implementation of "Quantitative Analysis of Automatic Image Cropping Algorithms: A Dataset and Comparative Study"?

The best maintained implementation is yiling-chen/flickr-cropping-dataset with 79 stars on GitHub. Confidence: high. Reproducibility: Limited.

Q: How reproducible is "Quantitative Analysis of Automatic Image Cropping Algorithms: A Dataset and Comparative Study"?

Estimated time to first reproduction: a few days. Risk flags: No CI workflows detected, Dependency manifest is missing. Start with yiling-chen/flickr-cropping-dataset and validate setup instructions in README.

Q: Are there pretrained models available for "Quantitative Analysis of Automatic Image Cropping Algorithms: A Dataset and Comparative Study"?

Yes, 1 Hugging Face model found. The top result is lincoln/mbart-mlsum-automatic-summarization with 236 downloads.

Q: What framework is used to implement "Quantitative Analysis of Automatic Image Cropping Algorithms: A Dataset and Comparative Study"?

The primary implementation uses none.

Published: Jan 1, 2017

Best maintained implementation now

Evidence: Direct

Domain fit: AI-adjacent

Verified repos: 1

Top repo stars: 79

Paper appears method- or tooling-adjacent to AI workflows with partial ecosystem coverage.

Framework: none

Time to first repro: a few days

2 risk flags

arXiv PDF

Technical details

Canonical key: arxiv-1701.01480

Cache status: Fresh

Generated at: Jun 17, 2026, 9:56 AM

Artifact coverage: direct

HF provider: ok (token)

PWC source used: Yes

LLM status: not_generated

LLM model: n/a

LLM generated: Unknown

LLM content type: n/a

HF policy: hf-relevance-v27

implementation starting point

Benchmarks: thin evidence

Time to repro: a few days

2 risk flags

none

Results & Benchmarks

Freshness tier: cold

Direct + Inferred Evidence

Computer vision

RankSVM

Overlap

0.6019

Source: paper fulltext

Computer vision

RankNet

Overlap

0.6015

Source: paper fulltext

Computer vision

RankBoost

Overlap

0.5017

Source: paper fulltext

Computer vision

eDN ( MaxAvg )

Overlap

0.3573

Source: paper fulltext

Computer vision

eDN ( MaxDiff )

Overlap

0.4857

Source: paper fulltext

Benchmark evidence drill-down

6 findings

Audit each benchmark finding before selecting an implementation path. Evidence refs map to the disclosure section below.

Task	Dataset	Metric	Value	Source	Evidence refs
Computer vision	RankSVM	Overlap	0.6019	paper-derived	No explicit refs
Computer vision	RankNet	Overlap	0.6015	paper-derived	No explicit refs
Computer vision	RankBoost	Overlap	0.5017	paper-derived	No explicit refs
Computer vision	eDN ( MaxAvg )	Overlap	0.3573	paper-derived	No explicit refs
Computer vision	eDN ( MaxDiff )	Overlap	0.4857	paper-derived	No explicit refs
Computer vision	BMS ( MaxAvg )	Overlap	0.3427	paper-derived	No explicit refs

Quantitative Analysis of Automatic Image Cropping Algorithms: A Dataset and Comparative Study is the primary contribution described in this paper.

Use This Implementation Because…

Confidence: high

yiling-chen/flickr-cropping-dataset is the strongest maintained implementation based on ranking signals. License is declared (MIT).

Open yiling-chen/flickr-cropping-dataset

Reproduction Risks

No CI workflows detected
Dependency manifest is missing

Hardware Notes

Expect multi-day setup/compute for meaningful reproduction based on current guidance.

Evidence disclosure

Evidence graph: 4 refs, 4 links.

Utility signals: depth 100/100, grounding 95/100, status high.

Implementation Comparison

Top 1 paths

Compare maintenance quality, reproducibility coverage, and evidence confidence before choosing a reproduction baseline.

yiling-chen/flickr-cropping-dataset

best maintained

Maintenance: Stale

Confidence: High

Reproducibility: Limited

Official implementation from Papers with Code · Repository link is mentioned in the paper metadata

Stars: 79
Last push: Feb 10, 2025 (493d ago)

Risk flags

No push in 12+ months
No CI pipeline detected
No tagged releases

Best implementation now

yiling-chen/flickr-cropping-dataset

Confidence: High

Reproducibility: Limited

A dataset that includes photos downloaded from Flickr and annotations that indicates a local window representing a good composition.

Stars: 79

Forks: 14

Last push: Feb 10, 2025

License: MIT

Official implementation from Papers with Code

Repository link is mentioned in the paper metadata

Strong overlap with paper title keywords

Community adoption signal (79 stars)

License ✓

CI –

Deps –

Docker –

Selected yiling-chen/flickr-cropping-dataset as the strongest maintained implementation for new work.
Repository activity is within the last 24 months.

Reproduction readiness

Major Work

Time to first repro: days

Last checked: Jun 17, 2026

Hardware requirements

Expect multi-day setup/compute for meaningful reproduction based on current guidance.

No dependency manifest — manual reconstruction required

· yiling-chen/flickr-cropping-dataset has no requirements.txt, environment.yml, pyproject.toml, or Dockerfile.
· You will need to reverse-engineer dependencies from import statements in the source code.
· Last push was 493 days ago.

Open yiling-chen/flickr-cropping-dataset