Skip to content
OpenTrain AIFor AI Companies

Adversarial Examples Are Not Bugs, They Are Features

Published May 1, 2019
arXiv PDF
Researcher verdict
Starting point
Use as implementation starting point
Benchmark evidence
Missing
Not verified yet
Time to first repro
A few days
Plan setup time
Risk flags
1
Review before use

Results and benchmarks

Freshness tier: cold
Adversarial Examples Are Not Bugs, They Are Features is the primary contribution described in this paper.

Implementation

Historical official implementation (not recommended for new builds)

Why this implementation
Confidence: low

MadryLab/constructed-datasets is the closest maintained adjacent implementation (Matched via arXiv identifier search). It is not paper-verified; validate algorithm and evaluation setup against the paper before trusting reported metrics. Community adoption signal: 187 GitHub stars.

Open MadryLab/robustness
Reproduction risks
  • Adjacent implementations are not paper-verified
  • Recommended repository is adjacent and not paper-verified.
  • Adjacent implementation match confidence is low.
  • No direct maintained implementation is currently verified.
  • Only historical official repository was found: MadryLab/robustness.
  • No maintained paper-verified implementation met reliability thresholds.

Compare implementation paths

Compare maintenance quality, reproducibility coverage, and evidence confidence before choosing a reproduction baseline.

MadryLab/robustness
historical official
Maintenance
Stale
Confidence
Medium
Reproducibility
Moderate
Stars
946
Last push
Jan 11, 2024 (957d)

Official implementation from Papers with Code · Community adoption signal (946 stars)

  • No push in 12+ months
  • No CI pipeline detected
  • No Docker setup
lengstrom/gitlinks
alternative
Maintenance
Stale
Confidence
Low
Reproducibility
Moderate
Stars
24
Last push
May 31, 2022 (1546d)

Matched via arXiv identifier search · Repository appears stale (>24 months since last push)

  • No push in 12+ months
  • No CI pipeline detected
  • No tagged releases
MadryLab/AdvEx_Tutorial
alternative
Maintenance
Stale
Confidence
Low
Reproducibility
Limited
Stars
15
Last push
Jul 23, 2020 (2223d)

Matched via arXiv identifier search · Repository appears stale (>24 months since last push)

  • No push in 12+ months
  • No CI pipeline detected
  • No tagged releases

Reproduction readiness

Time to first repro: days
Last checked: Aug 24, 2026

Setup required

Dependencies pinned, manual setup needed

  • MadryLab/robustness has requirements.txt but requires manual environment setup.
  • Last push was 957 days ago, so expect possible dependency version conflicts.
  • No Dockerfile, so you will set up the environment manually.
  • No CI pipeline, so test coverage is unknown.
Open MadryLab/robustness

Hardware requirements

  • Expect multi-day setup/compute for meaningful reproduction based on current guidance.

Quick start

git clone https://github.com/MadryLab/robustness.git
pip install -r requirements.txt

Repositories and ecosystem

Closest related implementations

These are not paper-verified. Use them as reference points when no direct implementation is available.

No additional verified repositories beyond the primary recommendation.

Hugging Face artifacts

No trustworthy direct or curated related Hugging Face artifacts were found yet. Use targeted searches to quickly locate candidate models, datasets, and demos.

Search models Search datasets Search spaces

Tip: start with models, then check datasets and spaces if you need evaluation data or demos.

Research context

Evaluation and human feedback data

Open this paper in HFEPX to review benchmark signals, evaluation modes, and human-feedback protocol context.

Open in HFEPX

Data includes links from Papers with Code ( CC-BY-SA-4.0 ).